Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I don't know if this is such a huge game changer for war. I mean, we had wheels for solid ground, and machines that can fly through the air, and boats for water, and hovercrafts for ambiguous terrain. These cute dogs are ultimately not that revolutionary.

I am much, much more worried about evil applications of multirotor drones.

Anyway, all of the above is an exercise in futility without decent AI. The robot dogs can run - so what? As long as they're pretty dumb they can't do much damage.

Now, an AI running a dog chassis, or flying a quadcopter, that's an "interesting" thought.



Wheels are notoriously poor at navigating rough terrain; that's why we build roads. We could build a vehicle with wheels or treads so huge it effectively flattens anything in its way, and we do -- but for some missions (support for a squad of soldiers on foot, say) it makes sense and is much cheaper to build a small legged vehicle.


Is it possible that these could make roads obsolete? Now that is an interesting concept.


Probably not because wheels are VERY efficient at transport across smooth level terrain, and a wheeled vehicle is less easy to destabilize than a legged vehicle. So when deciding between wheels vs. legs, it will be the usual sort of engineering tradeoff: which one offers the greatest advantage for your application?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: