Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Steel has a better failure story than carbon fiber. Many impacts that would shatter a carbon fiber frame, dangerous to the rider, will only bend a steel one. Carbon fiber makes sense for a racing bike, but for street riding I'll stick with steel.


A friend of mine was nearly killed on a carbon fibre frame that just tore itself apart while going up a hill and threw him into the road, unconscious. I would never touch one for street riding.


Was the frame damaged before? I have ridden 4k miles on my carbon road bike and I've never felt like it was going to fall apart.

I ride road/street almost exclusively, and the Bay Area roads don't do my bike any favors


Carbon fiber frames can be challenging to see the cracks and damages to it before it spectacularly fails. There's a good chance you won't know it is about to break until it shatters.


Any material under stress gets fatigued. The problem with carbon fiber specifically is that there are practically no visible signs of it reaching the threshold.


Some materials (steel and titanium being the most common) have infinite fatigue limits. They can be designed to not get fatigued.


Nope. As far as he knew it was in complete working order with no suggestion it was about to fail catastrophically until he woke up on the floor.


This is incredibly uncommon.

While horrifying for your friend, it's very low on the list of the risks that come with bikes.


It might be less uncommon than you think. https://www.outsideonline.com/outdoor-gear/bikes-and-biking/...


I don’t know how common it is, but why would you take that risk on the road for a couple kg of weight savings? If you’re racing competitively that’s one thing, but is it worth it on the commute?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: