Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I think most of these things were actually on Unix/Linux first, just maybe not as pretty as on OS X.


Lets go through the list:

* Spotlight - OS X

* Dock - NeXT

* Spaces - X11

* Software Repositories - Debian [1994]


Desktop search predates OSX with Beagle (unfortunately now defunct)


The first pitch I ever heard for Beagle was 'it's like searchlight', so I always assumed it came later- but I looked it up, and it's hard to tell. inotify 0.8 was announced about a month after Steve Jobs started advertising spotlight, and Beagle grew out of Dashboard which certainly has design documents that indicate they wanted to do that. So... I think you might be right.

On a related note, are you Ubuntu's jcastro?


Funny. Apple takes features from other OSes like Linux. Linux in turn takes features prominent in Apple's marketing strategy for OS X and replicate it in their own.


I'm pretty sure dash (quicksilver/spotlight) and the dock were in osx way before they appeared on linux.


Docks of one sort or another have been around for years. RISC OS had a dock-like icon bar in 1987, GNUStep nicked one from NeXTStep in 1994, and I'm sure there are earlier examples.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: